Contact Us Site Map

Making the Case

navigation - About CIC
navigation - Conferences and Events
navigation - Projects and Services
navigation - Tuition Exchange Program
navigation - For Presidents and CAOs
navigation - Making the Case
navigation - Publications


click for a printer friendly version
Don't Rule Out a Private School

By Bill Zlatos, Pittsburgh Tribune Review, August 6, 2006

Excerpt:

Cathleen Colbert, a senior last year at North Allegheny High School, yearned to go to Penn State. Her mother pushed Chatham College.

Coming from a single-parent home, Colbert planned to base her decision on financial aid. Chatham, although much more expensive than Penn State, offered to cover all but $8,000 of her expenses. Penn State left a $10,000 gap.

"It was so low as to be insulting to me," said her mother, Renee Colbert, 51, of Franklin Park. "I would have felt better if they said you're admitted, but there's no financial aid available."

Cathleen Colbert, now a sophomore at Chatham, knows what some families have yet to learn: Private schools, despite the Mercedes-Benz sticker prices, can end up costing the same as—or even less than—a public university.

"Shop around," advises Don Francis, president of the Harrisburg-based Association of Independent Colleges and Universities of Pennsylvania. "You shouldn't rule out a private institution based on the sticker price. You should find out what kind of financial aid package that institution will make to your son or daughter, or to you if you're going back to school."

Using data on average financial aid packages and estimated college expenses, the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review found that the actual cost to students and parents at many local private schools is comparable to the state's public flagships, the University of Pittsburgh and Penn State. The findings raise questions about which schools—public or private—really provide access to higher education in Pennsylvania.

"In a very real sense, we're doing the state schools' job for them," said Walt Fowler, vice president for finance at Chatham in Shadyside.

Students at private colleges and universities are more likely to attend smaller classes than at the state flagships. Private school students also are more likely to graduate in four years than those at state colleges and universities, according to the Washington, D.C.-based National Association of Independent Colleges and Universities.

back to top

Copyright ©1997-2008 Council of Independent Colleges. All rights reserved.